Ziff Davis Reports Google Search Referrals Down About 37% Year Over Year

Google organic search referrals to Ziff Davis sites fell about 37% year over year in Q3. Link impressions in AI features, however, are not the same as visits.

· 5 min read · 4 comments

Ziff Davis reported that referrals to its sites from Google organic search fell about 37% year over year in the third quarter. CEO Vivek Shah shared the figure with analysts on November 6, according to Search Engine Journal. In the same quarter a year earlier, referrals had fallen about 23%; over two years, they have more than halved. The company expects further declines. For site owners, it is a reason to track referral trends separately and not mistake link impressions in AI features for visits.

What the Search Console Numbers Show

On the same call, Shah cited a different figure: Ziff Davis’s digital media sites received about 2.7 billion link impressions in AI Overviews and AI Mode during the quarter. By his estimate, that is nearly ten times the number of clicks those same sites received from Google Search. Other sites with access to the Search Console report on generative AI features can compare these figures, too.

But these are different metrics. An impression means a link to a page appeared within AI Overviews or AI Mode. Those impressions are included in a site’s total Google Search impressions. Clicks on links in AI features are likewise counted alongside other search clicks.

Shah did not specify where he got the total click figure. If he used the overall Search Console figure, he compared impressions within AI features with all search clicks, including visits from AI Overviews, AI Mode, and other results. As of November 8, Google had not documented a separate click metric for AI features. So the ratio of 2.7 billion impressions to total clicks does not show the click-through rate of links in AI answers. It shows how often the links appeared, not how many visits they generated.

Where the Decline Is Sharpest—and What Supports the Business

Shah described changes in search traffic driven by Google and large language models as a headwind for the business. Ziff Davis’s technology and shopping properties are feeling the most pressure, he said. Their quarterly revenue fell 3.8% year over year to $82 million, although the pace of decline has slowed for three consecutive quarters.

The company’s total quarterly revenue fell 5.6% to $289.3 million. Shah explained why it did not fall as sharply as search referrals: the company has businesses that do not depend on Google traffic, including subscriptions and apps. He also mentioned commerce through social platforms and the relaunched RetailMeNot app.

IGN, the company’s largest site by search referrals, has held up relatively well so far, according to Shah. Some visits come from game walkthroughs and maps that are difficult to replicate, and the site also has substantial direct traffic. Still, revenue in the gaming and entertainment segment fell 2.1%. Shah attributed this to a weak gaming ad market ahead of the release of Grand Theft Auto VI later in November. Video—including vertical clips and social video—is also important to IGN’s business, he added, not just visits to its site.

What Site Owners and Marketers Can Do

If you have access to the Search Console report on generative AI features, you can record link impressions in AI Overviews and AI Mode for a given period alongside total search clicks for that same period. Then check separately how search referrals change over time. The comparison provides context, but it cannot establish that AI features caused a change in traffic.

To assess the impact, it also helps to look at business metrics: revenue, the performance of individual segments, and income streams that depend less on Google. At Ziff Davis, referrals are falling faster than overall revenue, but its technology and shopping properties face greater pressure. A single company-wide figure is not enough to understand how each category is doing.

More detailed data may become available later. The UK’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has given Google until December 3 to provide UK publishers with impression, click, and click-through rate metrics for AI search features, aggregated across features such as AI Overviews and AI Mode. It is not yet clear how Google will present the metrics. If clicks from AI features are separated from other clicks, publishers will be able to compare them with the corresponding impressions.

My Take: Impressions Are No Substitute for Visits

I would not make a decision about a website or marketing budget based on the ratio of AI impressions to all search clicks. The number looks impressive, but it does not answer a simple question: how many people came to the site from those impressions? I need a measurable connection between traffic and results, not a metric that is easy to misread.

I would also ask which parts of the business actually support revenue when search referrals decline. The Ziff Davis example does not prove that every site needs the same solutions. But it does give us a reason to check our own data before promising a traffic recovery or declaring AI search the sole cause of a decline.

Sources

Where the news comes from. The text is a retelling in the author’s own words; the facts come from the source, the opinion is the author’s.

  1. Ziff Davis Says Organic Google Referrals Fell About 37% via @sejournal, @MattGSouthern www.searchenginejournal.com

About the author

Gabi Vasiliou

client commissioning a website for a family guesthouse

I run a guesthouse in Cyprus and am choosing a contractor for a new website. Access to content, measurable results, and a clear answer about exactly what support includes all matter to me.

All posts by the author

Leave a comment

Not published. We’ll send a link to confirm your comment.

No links or ads. Your first comment is published after review. By sending a comment you agree to the privacy notice.

  1. That nearly 10-to-1 gap between AI-feature link impressions and Google clicks is pretty wild — impressions are doing a lot of heavy lifting in the headline there 😅 Do you know whether Ziff Davis saw the 37% referral drop across most of its verticals, or was it concentrated in a few? That breakdown would help separate a broad search shift from site-specific changes.

    1. The figures reported don’t include a vertical-by-vertical breakdown, so I can’t tell whether the decline was broad or concentrated; I’d want that detail before treating Ziff Davis as a template for smaller sites.

    2. @pim.pieters In my bike shop, I track organic visits separately from product impressions; impressions only matter if they lead to a visit or sale. I’d want the vertical breakdown before treating Ziff Davis’s 37% as a broad shift.

    3. @pim.pieters, I don’t see a vertical-by-vertical breakdown in the details quoted here, so I’d be cautious about calling the 37% a broad shift across every site. Did the article mention any category-level numbers elsewhere?